Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sarah Chekfa's avatar

Such a fascinating article! re: your first footnote, I was under the impression the recommended publications are ones that that specific owner of that Substack recommends, not recommendations algorithmically generated by Substack (source: a friend subscribed to my Substack in front of me and I saw the publications I recommended pop up in the drawer after she did so). If so, that just goes to advance your argument in a way (or it could be twisted in Substack’s favor — if they hadn’t been on Substack, they couldn’t have been recommended — implying other platforms don’t have this recommendation feature, which may be true).

Expand full comment
Anna Grigoryan's avatar

Few things I think about the supposed network effects of Substack.

1. the world of "network effects" is different for small newsletters compared to large newsletters. In case of many high profile newsletters like Lenny's Substack itself is putting great deal of work into promoting them. They [the newsletters] are featured on Substack's platform. The writers frequently give webinars to other writers, they are active on other social media. So those "network effects" for large newsletters are just that THEIR network effects rather than Substacks.

2. For small newsletters the window for network effects is considerably smaller. If the writer has no web 2.0 internet clout, they are relegated to random luck. And "internet luck" like a broken watch strikes the right time at least twice a day. For the small newsletter seeing 1 new sub from Substack network is a huge deal. While for the bigger one it's just another Tuesday. so there's that effect vs affect here. 1 new sub from Substack app is yay, dopamine, it doesn't mean that Substack is actually working.

I moved my newsletter to Ghost and i see the same "yay 1 new sub" dopamine after I publish. At the end of the day Substack like any platform that believes in it's own supremacy adds every feature specifically to keep the content supplies (us writers) on the platform, by providing the glitz and glamour of the regular dopamine hits or impressions of said dopamine hits.

Anyway... thanks for coming to my TED talk I guess :D

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts